Technical fault: must the airline pay?
Usually yes. Under case law an ordinary technical fault is not an extraordinary circumstance because it is part of normal flight operations.
The key points
- Rule: technical problems that occur in normal operation do not release the airline (CJEU, C-549/07 Wallentin-Hermann; C-257/14 van der Lans).
- Exception: a hidden manufacturing defect found by the manufacturer or an authority, or damage from outside influence (for example a bird strike or object on the runway), can be extraordinary.
- Proof: the airline must prove the circumstance and its reasonable countermeasures, such as maintenance records and the search for a replacement aircraft. “Technical problems” alone is not enough.
- Reform: from 23.10.2027 an ordinary fault is expressly not on the list of extraordinary circumstances (Article 6c).
What to do
- Ask in writing for the exact cause and maintenance history.
- Have the delay confirmed and keep your documents.
- Claim with a deadline and go to mediation if refused.
Continue with the compensation check, the claim letter or the tools. All changes of the EU reform: air passenger rights 2027.